Sunday, 24 June 2012

Making a point at the PLATT FIELDS 10K

 Over the last few years I've come to realise that leg strains occur not  so much due to  the training being done on the day that the pain comes so much as a result of the hard  training accomplished in the 3 or 4 days before.
 Things have generally been going pretty well since the SALE 5, the second of 5 races the Manchester Parks Grand Prix Series.  Perhaps too well. I hadn't race in the last 4 weeks and consequently I managed 3 weeks of sustained training with just the odd easy day per week.
 I was looking forward to better run at today's PLATT FIELDS 10K than last year particularly as the temperature would be far cooler.
 I finished last week with a pretty tough 2 lap trail circuit of the Strid Woods on the Saturday.   An undulating "up on the forefoot"  session which worked the calves well.  Sunday, trying to stay in touch with medium length runs I ran 12 on the canal.   Not overly swift but as usual a brisk second half.
"Coach" would have said, "you've had a tough weekend and you have a race next Sunday so do Monday and Tuesday at very easy pace,  a few 300s on Wednesday then ease down.
 I did  have an easy Monday running wise but was stood up all day at the shop; but  I attacked the 2 resrun too hard on the Tuesday , probably 4 minutes too hardt and as a result warming up for the 300s on the Wednesday the left calf (again) said...."If you put me through this, the moderate pain you are experiencing now will become acute and you will really suffer!!"  Session aborted. Very frustrating!  So....
 Thursday...........jog 2 .....not too clever.
 Friday............nothing......missed first day this year!
 Saturday...........jog 3.......not 100%...............but could probably manage the 10K distance.

Given the rain hitting the North West over the last few days I figured large parts of the PLATT FIELDS 10K  course would be under water and given the  vulnerable leg I went to bed on Saturday having decided to give it at a miss.  
 But with the weather forecast reasonable and given that I would probably cover 5 or 6 in training anyway I changed my mind and decided  to journey over the Pennines after all.
 Having committed to the 5 races in the Grand Prix I knew I would be disappointed not to complete them all;  I would not race 100% but if I could finish I would at least gain a point in towards my grand prix total.
 I warmed up with friend Brian Bradshaw from Sale and our fears that the trail section of the course would be under water were quickly realised.  Unfortunately so were several sections of the tarmaced park paths as well.   I  started to think that all things considered a time about 50 minutes would be satisfactory compared to 44.17 last year.  


 We hit the first stretch of water after just 2 minutes.  I was running alongside Brian but whilst I splashed through trying not to lift the knees and aggravate the hamstrings he pranced  through with high knee lift and immediately opened up a gap of 20 metres.  I felt the odd tweak in the lower calf but I was coping and at least managing sub 8 minute mileing  but Brian was maintaining the gap in front. (see pic above)
 On the garmin the miles reflected the "interval" nature of our efforts; working reasonably well on the dry parts, slowing down through the water.  7.27....7.55.....7.54.....7.49....7.26.
 I overtook a few on the 3rd of the 4 laps but at the five mile point decided to throw caution to the wind as they say ,  quite quickly closing  Brian down and  made a young Manchester Frontrunner the next target.
  As we splashed along the trail for the last time I was  singing the 3 Dog Night song, MAMA TOLD ME NOT TO COME! as I passed the marshal and slipped past my young rival who to his credit responded immediately by repassing me.  But he couldn't maintain his  charge around the lake as I prevailed, covering the 6th mile in 7.09 for a final time on my watch of 47.59.  At least I'd done one mile near to race pace.
 So to conclude  on the plus side, a good solid effort , a point gained towards my Grand Prix total and still a chance of completing all 5 races.
                        On the negative side..............tell you after tomorrow's test jog!











Wednesday, 13 June 2012

A STRESSFUL ILKLEY 8 MILE ROAD RACE 1987

  A lovely lady came into the shop yesterday representing a new club situated between Settle and  Lancaster.  VALERIE HARROLD of BENTHAM BEAGLES Running Club had entry forms for the club's  10K which will be held for the first time on Sunday 22 July.
  She expressed concern that they had only received 6 entries at the moment and the race would incur a heavy loss but we tried to assure her that no doubt there will be a significant flow of entries between now and the July date and of course many will enter on the day.
  Her concerns reminded me of  the risks involved in putting on a race today with increasing expenditure but still it was good to hear of  a young club being keen to put back into the sport by hosting an event themselves.  Check out more details at  www.benthambeagles.co.uk
  Hopefully the race will not upset local motorists as Ilkley Round Table's 10K did. In hindsight perhaps going metric and changing the course was a bad idea.  The two lap 8 miler  we started off with was clearly a safer course which  was less likely to hold up Sunday morning drivers.
  It was  the challenge  several hundred local runners faced this date  25 years ago.....

JUNE 14 1987  THE ILKLEY ROUND TABLE 8 MILE ROAD RACE.
  There are no doubt several people reading this blog right now who are as fitter and faster than 99% of the population but are reluctant to return to racing because of the weight and pressure of expectation.  
 Previous success leads others to expect that high achievement will continue. But after injury or a period off racing through other aspects of life,  the fear of not reaching former levels is sadly enough to put many off racing altogether.
 I was always extremely  nervous for this race in my home town,    much the same as I was when competing in the school sports from the age of 14.   Having represented Lancashire etc.  I was expected to win 2 or 3 events at the school sports but particularly trying to win over 880 yards (800 mts) was never a certainty when 400 runners of similar county standard moved up. But  as house captain I had to turn out for the points.
 Having won a couple of marathons, half marathons etc the weight of expectations was similarly great for this local race.  But 2 laps of 4 miles with a steep ascent and descent was another challenge altogether!  I recall the day also being extremely stressful as I had had a hand in the organisation with the Round Table and then there would be the task of holding off Ilkley Harriers
new "star" runner, a 23 year old JAMES PARKER who was rapidly making a name for himself.
 But as usual once the adrenalin kicks in and the focus is on the race itself things go pretty well.
At 38 I was alongside  many fast young guns on the start line but  managed 8th place by the end of the tough event.  It was excellent day for VALLEY STRIDERS with 4 of us in the first 11.
The race was won by CHRIS PROCTOR of then KEIGHLEY ROADRUNNERS in 41:13
followed by  MARTIN HOPSON  (VALLEY STRIDERS)  42:07  and a young MARTIN ROSCOE (Leeds University) who is now one of the country's best vets in his age group. 
My old friend HILARY McEWAN was 4th.
  JAMES PARKER  edged me out by 12 seconds for first local in 6th place  to my 8th. 43:08 to 43:20.  He went to enjoy much success on the fells particularly before turning to biking and rowing.
 First lady in the race was fellow Valley Strider JO FRICKER who now works in the FASTRAX part of my business ensuring there is a steady flow of vests, t-shirts, hoodies etc to our clubs in G.B. and the Republic Of Ireland.
 This was the first of 3 consecutive weeks of local races.  Could she manage a hat trick of wins?
                                        



Tuesday, 5 June 2012

ILKLEY TRAIL RACE VIDEO(S)...

A real Sunday feeling to this Tuesday's trek along the normally quiet back lanes of the town towards Bolton Abbey. It seemed so many people chose to celebrate their jubilee holiday by digging out their old bikes and
giving it their all alongside the usual "professionals". Not the most relaxing of runs!
 So another morning with hundreds of bikers and just 2 runners. Well, 3 including me.  A contrast to yesterday when 219 turned out to run the 5th Annual ILKLEY TRAIL RACE.
 The race is one of many events which have evolved from road races.  Originally muted by the local Round Table as a fun run,  it became a "legal"  8 mile, 2 lap road race......went metric as a 10K road but as the Round Table bowed out under the weight of complaints from motorists was adopted by ILKLEY HARRIERS.   After early course problems the route devised in conjunction with race director Lawrence Basham seems to work and is challenging but runnable unlike races on the other side of the valley which are more geared to the dedicated fell runner.
 For once we were blessed with pretty good weather but I must confess I abandoned filming at the uppermost point where it was becoming distinctly chilly!
 They say if it isn't broke don't mend it.......well I changed a filming routine which lead to editing into 2 parts.................

Sunday, 3 June 2012

ILKLEY MOOR RUN 1987... a gruelling run?

It was shades of the Manchester marathon conditions today with a low temperature of just 6 degrees, steady rain and  a blustery cooling easterly wind .  Tempting to settle for a short run in such conditions but having driven over the hill to battle up and back on the canal,  I stuck to plan,  persevering to bring week 20 to a close with a moderately paced 11 miler.  Compensation being that the dreadful weather put off the bikers who normally wizz past on the towpath with undue care and much abandon.  Just 4 seen all morning!
 No track session this week but a good solid week's training  after last Sunday's 5 mile race.  Particularly pleasing being one of the fastest circuits of the res in a long time; probably because I had company for the first 3 miles which meant I started faster than normal!  44 miles on the week.  912 on the year and the average over 41. No days missed this year; so have to be pleased with the consistency which I hope will lead to some good race performances  over the next few months.


                                TIM      JOHN       HILARY   BEN      TERRY           CHRIS
                             AGAR CONVERY McEWAN  GRANT LONERGAN LEGGATT

 Tomorrow's it's time for the annual ILKLEY TRAIL RACE which covers a route on the north side of town.  This weekend 25 years ago the ILKLEY MOOR RUN took place.  It was the 5th event in the Leeds Grand Prix of that year,1987.  A series in which I continued to place second fiddle to my young rival, JOHN CONVERY , who had maintained his position on top of the leader board with a string of wins, whilst I had tried to stay in touch at least with a second and a couple of 4th places.
 This day would be a slightly different challenge.  Not a shortish road race as the previous events had been.
The local paper the WHARFE VALLEY TIMES described it as a "gruelling 13.5 mile run over the top of Ilkley Moor.  In truth I would suggest there was not a lot of climbing in the run compared to the 700 feet which runners will face tomorrow; but a good challenge nevertheless.
 304 completed the race which started and finished in Guiseley.  JOHN CONVERY would maintain his position as Grand Prix leader but had to content with second in the race.  He was beaten by Harrogate's BEN GRANT.  Ben  Grant is nearly 64 now but is still racing and still capable of a 5K just under 20 minutes!  He has enjoyed an excellent career with success on and off road as he showed this day 25 years ago beating John by over 5 minutes.
  In 6th place was CHRIS LEGGATT, a Sale Harrier teammate in the '60s who  was then a Valley Striders teammate.  Pictured here crossing Ilkley Moor with me two places back.
I  ran an isolated 7th  (2ND Grand Prix entrant) with  KEVIN O'HARA 9TH  and my now departed friend HILARY McEWAN  10TH.
  LINDA LORD (Clayton)  was first lady followed by local Skyrac ladies, CATH RILEY and ALICE GULL.

                 1.  BEN GRANT                  HARROGATE              83.35
                 2.  JOHN CONVERY          VALLEY STRIDERS   88.39
                 3.  M. HOLLIDAY               LEEDS CITY                90.05
                 4.  M. FALGATE                  PUDSEY                      91.17
                 6.  CHRIS LEGGATT           VALLEY STRIDERS   92.22
                 7.  TERRY LONERGAN       VALLEY STRIDERS  93.28
                 9.  KEVIN O'HARA              UNATTACHED          94.38
                10. HILARY MC EWAN        VALLEY STRIDERS  95.04


A  fortnight later many of us gathered  again for the event which preceded tomorrow's trail race, the Ilkley 8 mile road race.  Another race in which the white and black of Valley Striders would feature to the fore.

Tuesday, 29 May 2012

SALE HARRIERS 5 MILER

My pre-race thoughts last Sunday  can probably best be summarised as follows........


 I DON'T NEEDTHIS...............I don't really feel I've recovered from two weeks ago.
 I DON'T NEED THIS..............I feel ***ckered from standing up at work for hours this week.
 I DON'T NEED THIS.............the temperature is going to mid 20s....why bother!?
 I DON'T NEED THIS..............my head's blocked up from hayfever or do I have a head cold?
 I DON'T NEED THIS...............it's bound to be a P.W. for a 5 miler.


 BUT in line with many I spoke to the SALE (HARRIERS) 5 MILE ROAD RACE  was the second race of 5 in the Manchester Parks Grand Prix and we were ultimately all keen to maintain our presence in the series.  Having to commit and remain fit over a period is a real  incentive  and advantage of taking part in a Grand Prix series, isn't it?
 So it was a case of don extreme weather white mesh club vest, white cap and sunglasses and go for it!
At least I hadn't raced for a fortnight;  several were talking about having raced on Friday night, many spoke about having raced yesterday in their weekly parkrun, and perhaps regretted it as the temperatures sored.  But club mate and follower Frank C. made it 3 in 3 days even after a half marathon in Latvia last week.  Well done, Frank. Couldn't do it at my age, I'm afraid.
  We arrived in plenty of time and for once I had a reasonable warm up.  For "warm up" read loosener ; just stepping out of the car we were warm enough.  I joined the small select field of just 146 runners and slottted in to the left of the start line to stay out of the basically. Good job.  I  thought I had a couple of minutes to relace my untied shoes  but then  the gun went. Fortunately as was at the side of the track as every single entrant swept past.  Some start!  Some handicap.  Last out of the blocks.  I managed to overtake 77.
 Still it forced the adrenalin to kick in perhaps more than normal and I think I managed to run to expectations except I just failed to catch M65, MIKE CUNNINGHAM of Manchester A.C. who was first M65 ; my consolation being that I was first M60 and of course 1st M60 in the Grand Prix as a bonus.
 My splits on the course based on the placing of the mile markers were
7.01  7.57  6.28  7.01  6.41..............35.14   (A personal worse but not too bad all things considered)
But official time on results sheet  35.24. 
  Conclusion ...it took me 10 seconds to tie my shoe lace up and someone didn't quite get the placing of the mile markers correct. But more importantly some race days go a lot better than you think they are going to go when you first step out of the car on arrival.

Monday, 28 May 2012

SALE 5 MILE VIDEO

It was a hot one...........!!

Thursday, 24 May 2012

Failure to focus ?

No matter how we express it,  "withdrawing from your fitness banks" ,  "breaking down walls" or whatever,  put simply racing takes it out of us all. No matter how old we are.
 But it's so often said that recovering from races getting harder as we age.  After the Beaverbrooks 10K, a week last Sunday, in which I had to work very hard to run  43 minutes,  it was 6 days later on the following Saturday that I felt up to getting anyway near that race pace.  Last week was a hard week indeed.
  The track session of 10 x 600 metres reps with 200 metre jog recovery was executed at 45 mins pace
with the temperature showing 4 degrees and me dressed as if the calendar was reading February.  Desperate stuff.  A stark contrast to today with the temperature getting well over 20.
 Another indication of the impact of that 10K was shown in comparing last week's and this week's 2 res run. Last week, again in cold blustery  conditions,  64.15.  Yesterday, despite a temperature of 19  degrees...59.15. So 5 minutes faster. Perhaps I just thrive with a bit of  sun on my back!
 Of course , you young 'uns often take a different view with regard to races.  Take one local  F50 who prepared for a hilly marathon last week by running a club league race on the Tuesday night and not content with that slotted in a sub 20 mins 5K on the Wednesday night.  A different view to marathon taper; but a time which "forecasted" to about 3:10.  She ran 3:26 and  missed out on a category win in the marathon by t just 3 minutes?!  Failure to focus,perhaps or just enjoying racing?
 I follow the progress of a club mate who in his late teens was at much the same level as me as a steeplechaser. His times recently have been a tad disappointing but he did go back under 9 minutes last year.  He ran in a fairly prestigious 3k steeplechase last Sunday but missed on a sub 9 mins clocking by ten seconds.  The night before he had raced a 1500 metre race, finishing 11th.  Failure to focus, pehaps?
 The great wee man, Haile, ran a superb Great Manchester 10K time of 27.39 and will turn out again this Sunday in Hengolo, Netherlands supposedly  in an attempt to gain an Olympic place over the same distance, having missed out on  a marathon place.   Will he still have that road 10K in his legs and miss out?  We'll see on Sunday. Would you have raced the Manchester with the trial 7 days later? Failure to focus perhaps ?
 I know many vets like to race every week. I've queried this with a few and they tell me in between they just "tick over", doing no track sessions; they use  the races as their speed work.  It's an approach which seems to work for many; but  I'm not sure it would work for me.  I'm not sure I want to be heading out every Sunday morning or even earlier for 9.00 a.m. parkruns.
   I think I'm  strong enough to race pretty well a couple of times each month at the moment but perhaps try to "peak" for a few key  races where the courses are particularly conducive to a  good performance. Hopefully I can maintain that approach until  November then ease down for a few weeks.




Friday, 18 May 2012

JOHN CARR 5K SERIES RACE 3 VIDEO

  The ever growing strength of the parkrun empire is having a bit of knock out effect on 5ks organised by running clubs.  Salford Harriers moved their Sunday 5K to a Thursday night.  Our club dropped our 5K as their is a weekly parkrun in the same park.  But the club has persevered with a heavily marketed 5K series, the Sizzlers,  Lancaster & Morecambe are still running the Saturday night 5K series.
  Locally, the newly named SALTAIRE STRIDERS (formerly St. Bede's A.C.)  have enjoyed success with their JOHN CARR 5K sreies of 3 5Ks despite the weather!
  I popped down to the nearby village of Esholt , where Emmerdale was filmed before they built their  own Emmerdale village,  and witness 308 thrash out a fast furious 5K.
 Sally M. said she had secured a late entry and said that they had reserved a number for me as well; but, one,
my asthmatic lungs do not work well on a course which is largely based in a sewage works(!) and two, last Sunday's 10K took a lot out of me and there was no way I was going to extend myself again just 3 days later!
 Not a great evening for filming with the setting sun but here's a flavour of the action......




Wednesday, 16 May 2012

BEAVERBROOKS 10K..it takes all sorts!

 In order to secure an entry on the day, I arrived quite early for last Sunday's BEAVERBROOKS 10K in Blackpool.  As I walked across the Hilton Hotel car park to enter I thought it was unusual to be racing on the Fylde Coast in a race NOT organised by Ron Mc Andrew of fyldecoastrunning.    But as chance would have it, Ron was the very first person I met as I reached the basement door of the hotel.  He would be marshaling today. He quip was,
                                                "Terry Lonergan doing a fun run!".   

When the charity event first started in 1982 it was an issue whether club runners should take part as it was not a "registered" event.  There was talk of local AAA officials out spying to make a note of any club runners taking part and have them banned! Not sure if that ever happened but
certainly many club runners wore alternate vests for the day.
 I stuck to that practice on Sunday but  times have changed; with no threat of a ban many local runners wore Wesham and Blackpool colours as normal.
 However, as an unregistered race, our performances will not appear on Power Of 10 records.
Probably justified as times seemed to have been rounded up/down to the nearest 15 seconds!
According to the results 17 of us crossed the line in exactly 43 minutes. Some deadheat!!
  The leading runners were heading back up as we approached the Pleasure Beach and club runners obviously made up the first dozen places or so.  But around me I would say the majority were "unattached".  Many young men with talent and potential running an occasional race but not in local clubs.
 The results show hundreds under 35 took part; yet this is the age group so lacking in "normal" club races.  The question is then, how do we get them to join our running clubs?
  
Over my 50 years of competing,  relationships are established with runners, like Ron McAndrew who I first competed against in 1968.  Relationships often established  actually during  the race itself.   Not a conversation as you might have when training of course but a bit of race banter and  then the inevitable after race post mortem. 
 Sunday saw little of that as nearly every runner around me was listening to music.  Now you might say it was a good thing they couldn't hear me but they cut out a lot of the atmosphere of the event.
The cheering of the holiday makers lining the route,  the sounds emitting from the arcades on the Golden Mile,  the screams from the Big Dipper on the Pleasure Beach,  the clanking of the trams, the cries of the seagulls. And no real rapport with fellow runners; no relationships developed!
 With no real malice intended, quite often fellow runners say to me, "you're not the runner you were,  are you, Terry?  With two fingers forming a "V" either side of my nose, I point out that I am 63 and the years of competition have taken something of a toll. 
 However, taking part in mass participation events such as the Beaverbrooks brings home the opposite. Compared to the general running public,  we are in fact pretty fit indeed. 
 In the recent Salford 5K with 106 in it I was nearly half way down the field  in 52nd place.
                      Here with I was in the top 6% of the 2500 who took part.  
                        It was that kind of event. Nice for a change, I suppose.














Monday, 14 May 2012

BEAVERBROOKS 10K 2012...fun at the seaside?

I generally tend to shy away from so called "mass participation" events  with the exception of the Great Manchester 10K in my home town. But having finished only 4th in the M60 age group last year, though I'm convinced one who beat me was running as his father, I failed to win a "prize" entry. So instead I thought I would reaquaint myself with the delights of the BLACKPOOL promenade and race the BEAVERBROOKS 10K.
 The 30th running of a FUNRUN which helps participants raise thousands of pounds for charity whilst giving "serious" runners the chance of a fast outing ; just short of 5K down to the famous Blackpool pleasure beach and (ideally) a fast belt back up the promenade. Simple. Simple, providing the weather is perfect!
 But as is so often the case on the west Fylde coast the wind played a part in spoiling the party. Not so simple.
Very often we race in windy conditions and afterwards we say "the wind never seemed to be behind us did it?"  Yesterday,  there was no mistaking the way the race would go.  True to the BBC weather forecast,  chilly, strong south westerly winds  brought flags along the promenade to horizontal and we knew the first half of the journey, south towards the  Pleasure Beach would be hard . Very hard.
As usual  I was still warming up as over 2 thousand other runners stood in place suffering the sea breezes.  I came onto the course and slipped a few ranks behind the "serious" sub 40 minute runners.  Many looked as if they were running their first race; never mind able to run sub 40 mins!!
 Inevitably the start was a tad traumatic.  Elbows set at shoulder height in "defensive mode".  The cold, wind working against the old heart and breathing.  The "young guns" were now passing  me by the dozen.  Spiderman flew past to my left.  5 extremely fit looking young men flew past to my right clad in head to foot lycra body suits with no visible holes for breathing.  Blue, yellow, black, green and red.  Were they the Olympic rings running in formation, full of chat and high spirits as they sped on away from me in their Morphsuits!
 I figured today then would be a case of participation. One for surviving the first 5K and trying to salvage something on the way back for a solid run. Nothing more.
 And so it seemed as we went through 2k in 9.03. and followed with splits around 4.30 going through 5k in 22.26.   But.......
 I spy Spiderman now at the side of the road; he is peeling down the top half of his lycra suit. he has expired.  The Olympic ring runners have broken rank. They too have unpeeled. The top half of their Morphsuits around their waists.  Now they can breath!
But the relief of battling against the strong winds elevated the spirits. Unlike small races where it's often the case of running solo, here there was always someone to fight as they came past, always someone to chase, always someone to run shoulder to shoulder with. And so the acceleration came........
 6th K....4.11.....7K....4.10.....8K  4.05!
Disappointingly we were not turned down onto the lower promenade at this point but carried on
slightly uphill past the start and we slowed to 4.20 but with plenty still to aim for,.....................
 Somehow despite that first 5K we were now racing to dip under 43 minutes as we now turned onto the lower  walk but for me the wind, now against us again  for the last few hundred yards proved too strong and at least on my watch, I just missed out by 3 seconds but the results read 43.00 for a whole group of us.
But 3.50 for the last kilometre?  Possibly a bit short?
 Besides the "batch timing" be prepared for results only by age group if you ever run this one.   At 63 I was put in the 55 and over group, not the usual M60 category,  but was still pleased to finish  3rd of 170.
           All in all a good day out on the coast but we could have done without that wind!

Thursday, 10 May 2012

Jack Bloor Race 2012

 For once the weather for the 27th annual Jack Bloor Senior fell race was tolerable; although true to form by the time the prize giving took place,  many were complaining of being bitten by midges as usual. 
 As the Complete Runner were co sponsoring once more with the Ilkley Brewery Company popping up the moor from home provided a pleasant break from the delights of the print room where on the Fastrax side of the business we are extremely busy getting your club vests etc out!
 Unfortunately it's not an event easily covered midrace but I hope the following video captures the atmosphere around the start and finish area............


Saturday, 5 May 2012

MANCHESTER MARATHON POSTSCRIPT

The daily running has been hard this week. Not hard because of any real pace. Just hard work.  I had put the tiredness down to reaquainting myself with  developments in the FASTRAX print room which has seen me standing   printing for several hours each day.  With a staff retirement ,a  necessary exercise; one, to ensure that the vest ordered continued to flow out and two , so that I am able to teach new recruits how to cope with the orders in turn.   Printing your club vests is often more difficult than you night imagine.
 So standing for several hours a day,  has been a factor . However, when I measured how far I had run in supporting  Sally Malir's superb GREATER MANCHESTER MARATHON , I found that it was 18  miles in total!  Hardly surprising the miles since have been somewhat laboured.

 Going back to Sunday the running forums have been awash with comments about the race.  Many have praised the marshals, many from my own club Sale Harriers, and the people of south Manchester who not only gave vocal support but as the day's cold, very wet conditions continued throughout the morning came out to give much needed comfort, shelter and physical support to so many runners struggling from half way.
 But the majority have mentioned the inefficiency of the bag retrieval system.  In short, it was "back to front" which meant that as the faster runners entered the tent asking the cadets for their bags which couldn't be found, the queue then developed OUTSIDE the tent.  Now on a warm, spring morning this meant not have been so bad but to have run 26.2 miles and then have to queue with just a "space blanket" for warmth was not welcomed by the runners. Many perhaps not unexpectedly , let's just say, became quite inpatient so much so that I am told the army cadets deserted their posts or were told to retire to leave a free for all!
 That aside, once I had ensured she did not suffer hyperthermia, Sally's day went  very well.  By coincidence, we were back in Longford Park, Stretford, on Tuesday night with Sal's daughter, Georgia. (She ran 10:44 for the 3K as a season opener) A comment was made to me that Sally " lost it" in the second half!   His  broken nose is mending nicely!
  Far from "losing it"  her pace per mile, targeted at 7.15, never drifted to over 8.00, she overtook  65 men from the midway point and  3 women to come through from 5th to 2nd within yards of  the line.  Not exactly "losing it".  Obviously begs the question  though, , what time would she have run in favourable conditions!!
  A quick scan of the top 100 in the race shows that all "lost" several minutes over the second half.  The rain was bad enough; but it was the low 4 degrees and wind chill that did the damage.  Given the weather forecast  it suggested it really would be a marathon of winter conditions, I am so surprised that so many elected to race in just vest and shorts( see pic above).
 Better weather today though.  Bright blue skies over Wharfedale. Over a week since the Salford 5K and time finally to try to inject a bit of pace back into the old legs with a track session!  Bring it on.



Sunday, 29 April 2012

A splashing time at the MANCHESTER MARATHON

 Looking out of the bedroom at 5.45 a.m. this morning  the trees were fairly still, it was dry and if conditions had remained that way then  it would have been a good marathon running day.  But  the BBC WEATHER forecast for the Manchester area would have had to have been hopeless wrong to give the 8000 entered any hope of favourable conditions for today's GREATER MANCHESTER MARATHON. 
 I set off from Yorkshire at 7.00 am and the rain hit the windscreen as entered the red Rose country of Lancashire at 7.30. Put simply it then just became worse and worse as the day went on.  Manchester duly lived up to its reputation for rain. And did it rain!
                                                   Manchester Evening news picture
 There seemed little doubt that all the plans and projections SALLY MALIR and I made in our prerace discussions on Thursday would be washed away on the rain soaked  streets of South Manchester.  Based on her times in a tough hilly half (Liversedge) and a tough hilly 20 (Spen 20) we decided that a target time 3:10 would be achievable  and that would mean 7.15 pace per mile.  Who knows perhaps a top 10 placing and possibly a category win as a bonus?
 I met up with Sal minutes before the race and she peeled off her sodden "binliner" and sodden longsleeve and went up to take her place just behind the fast  men.  With the rain continuing to fall the field was still behind the line at 9.05 as announcements continued to be made.  5 minutes late, the very frustrated assembled masses left and sped out to complete a loop around Old Trafford before looping back and heading south into the Cheshire suburbs.
 Meanwhile I shot down the Cheshire Ring canal to spot her at 6 and 8.  She passed by looking easy and relaxed shoulder to shoulder with Jessica, a young Trafford A.C. runner. She was slightly up on time and was sharing 5th place.  So far, so good. But it was early days.
 I continued on south on the canal heading  towards Altrincham. By this time despite wearing winter tights, a baselayer tee, a midlayer longsleeve and a Windstopper jacket I was getting decidedly chilled and pretty wet myself.  Some compwtitors were just running in vests and shorts ....you can imagine!
 At the 25K point the course dipped underneath the canal and I joined several other supporters taking  shelter under the bridge. We stood shivering  together as the runners bravely battled on by.   The order of the ladies was as it had been at 8 miles. Jessica, the Trafford girl though had edged away from Sally who was now a distinct 5th.
 She waved away my offer of a lightweight rainjacket to help her cope with the heavy rain and gales to come in those last 17K and ran out of sight.  Still looking pretty strong and moving well.
 With the canal towpath by now resembling a river, I decided to run back the longer way up the Chester Road;hopefully to pick up the action again at the 26 mile point.  Dressed for winter running it was a tough slog back up towards Stretford and the finish.
 Within minutes of  reaching that point the first lady, REBECCA JOHNSON, Bellahouston, came by. then a second  and a few minutes later young Jessicas emerged from the underpass with Sally just 60 metres or so behind in 4th.  But young Jessica was wilting and wilting rapidly.
The gap shortened dramatically on the hill as Sally mounted a last late charge to gain a place "on the podium".  I ran alongside for 100 metres or so, shouting her on like a mad man, but I could barely keep up!  I lost sight as she peeled off into the finishing straight still in 4th but within seconds she had forged into 3rd place!
 I looked at the finish clock and it was still reading under 3:12.  But she was already well into the finish funnel.   In torrential rain and high winds from 25K she only amazingly clocking 3:10.45.
Certainly suggests she is in shape to have run around 3:06/ 3;07.
It was a truly  fine performance; a great reward for all her hard work in a campaign which began, not 12 weeks ago or 16 weeks ago but way back in October with the target being to run 18 miles by Christmas then REALLY  focus on today.
  She left the finishing funnel, tired, soaked through, cold but elated with her run.
It was then that it all could have gone so very, very wrong........and I fear for many it did......but more of that to follow!

Friday, 27 April 2012

SALFORD 5K...going downhill,literally.

Despite 2012 being my 50th year of competitive running last night's SALFORD 5K was only my 35th. over that distance. I'm sure many of you reading this know a runner or two who ran more 5Ks in 2011 than as they live out an addiction to weekly parkruns.  
 I should say for accuracy that the race did not take place in Salford but in Manchester's Heaton Park but was put  on by Salford Harriers. They are not based in Salford either. Their base is in North Manchester!  So there you go....
 The club introduced a "new faster course" last night which took out the traditional uphill drag to the hall after the K and was essentially overall a downhill route.
   The start in front of the famous Heaton Hall  brought  a severe shock to the system.  (Un) familiarity then with the distance breeds contempt!  But I was conscious of the calf strain I suffered last time out over this distance at the Moor Park 5K last November in Preston and was forced to limp around to record 23.32.  Consequently having circuited the hall grounds twice before emerging on to the old course I was lagging on several I would normally expect to beat.
 As used the adrenalin kicked in after the first K and I managed to pull a few back.  Perhaps if the warm up had been better the adrenalin would have kicked from the start!  but by the time we'd discovered where they were giving out the numbers, ran around with everyone else discovering that all the nearby public toilets were closed  and prepared generally there was only 30 minutes to the off.  Less time that it takes to awaken my aged bones and cardio system.
 Last night  without any real feedback from K markers and hence no eye to the watch  it was simply a call for outright racing.  Concentrating on those just ahead with an eye to those just overtaken to ensure they remained behind!  To that end I think the race went well with no one overtaking from 1K.  The time was of no concern until crossing the line.
 As the video shows I was back in 60th position or so after the two circuits around the hall but managed to fight  through to 52nd of the moderate field of 102.  4th in the age group and a clocking of 21.32.   Solid but room for improvement I would say.
 Switching the race to a Thursday night ,presumably to not clash with the Sunday parkrun and possibly attract some of their runners, saw the number rise to 102 from 85 last year and once the word gets around about the new faster "down hill" course I'm sure this will continue to rise.






Wednesday, 25 April 2012

Running Grand Prix.........good or bad?

It's not often that I abort a training run or session.  I must admit to having been extremely tempted as I arrived at the track last Thursday to do a rep session of 8 x600.  As I parked and turned  off the engine,  the rain swept across the deserted tartan track in front of me. With the prospect of a hard session in front of me and not even the reward of a nice hot shower in the adjacent changing rooms at the end of it,   it was a bleak prospect.   But I had driven 40 minutes to get there so, of course, I endured it and as the weather rapidly changed  from bad to slightly better to bad again the session was duly completed.
 Today I was looking forward to breaking up the day with a gentle 4 mile prior to tomorrow's SALFORD 5K in Heaton Park, Manchester.  Ever the pessimist I had donned tights and a Goretex jacket (typical April attire!) but I hadn't expected what was to come. Within minutes freezing, cold rain swept across the fields in torrents.  So much for global warming!!
Not so much as an April shower as an April deluge. After 2 miles I had just had enough.  I decided that another 20 minutes or so was probably going to do more harm than good and called it a day morning!
  Tomorrow the weather may be no better as we set off,  but set off we will. The MANCHESTER PARKS GRAND PRIX with its 5 races prepaid guarantees a great degree of commitment from tomorrow through until September.  Previously featuring a drag UP to Heaton hall, this year the measured course will START at the hall and snake DOWN to the tram station.  Easy, peasy!...hopefully.


 I'm not sure I would have been so keen if the Grand Prix had involved more races.  The PENDLE and BURNLEY Grand Prix takes in 15 races with 9 to count.  It encourages versatility with 5 road, 5 trail and 5 fell in the mix but "specialists" can choose to compete in say just 5 road races for which there is a separate category award.  It's well thought through and with the price of petrol nowadays may prove more popular than ever,  as obviously all the races are in a confined area.  Whether you are happy to compete against the same people up to 15 times over the summer is another matter.
 1987: LEEDS LEISURE SERVICES GRAND PRIX
At this time 25 years ago we were well into a new Grand Prix organised by Leeds Leisure Services in conjunction with Valley Striders and Skyrac A.C.  8 races made up the Grand Prix as I recall : races of various distances using Leisure centres around Leeds as the race venue.
 At 38 years of age there was no way I was going to be able to match the performances of 25 year old club mate, JOHN CONVERY. Only thought was whether he would commit to all 8 of the events. With a points structure giving 200 for first, 199 for second etc. one race missed would make for a massive loss of points.
 As expected John beat me by 42 seconds in the first event, the ROTHWELL 6.5 (33.50 TO 34.32) and scored a second win  to my 3rd 3 weeks later in KIPPAX.  400 points then to my 397.  But could he keep it up?  Could stay loyal to the series or stay loyal to races further afield I'd traditionally competed in?




Sunday, 22 April 2012

Success and failure of GB elite at London Marathon

Well I hope JO PAVEY is not a Manchester United supporter. If she is, she has had a very disappointing day indeed.  Having decided to rest on her laurels with her 2 2011 marathon times of 2:28.42 (New York) and 2:28.24 (London) and hope that no GB girl(s) would rob her of the 3rd Olympic place she must have had a very, very anxiuos morning. If she bear to watch at all!
  She played her cards and just hoped that no one would produce a better hand.  She was wrong.
If she felt she held all the aces. It would appear her dream of racing the London Olympic marathon has gone up in smoke!
  How she must have felt when CLAIRE HALLISEY came round that corner with 200 metres to go and it looked certain she was going to go under 2:28. Then to add to her painful disappointment FREYA MURRAY came into view and she too beat her banked time.
 Not only did she decide not to race today but she has not raced all this year; so the decision for the electors tomorrow looks to be a very easy. Pavey has no recent form to convince them that she is in better form than Hallisey.   It will be interesting to see if she reverts to the 10K to secure an Olympic place.
 There is an argument to suggest that none of the ladies should have been preselected.  Times recorded a year ago in  a marathon are surely no indication of the level of fitness for the Olympic marathon in 16 weeks time.  I would have adopted the U.S.A. approach of first 3 past the post selected to race again in August. Plenty of time to recover. If Kenya could use the London Marathon as a trial, why couldn't we?
 As for the GB men, LEE MERRIEN ran 2:13.41 for a PB, first GB runner but well outside the 2:12 he was aiming for and it looks likely Scott Overall will be our only GB Olympic participant.
 Significantly, Merrien's PB time only takes him to equal 73rd on the UK all time marathon rankings. Perhaps going to Kenya to train is over rated?!
 At least the weather was favourable for the first few thousands this morning.  I know up in the North East conditions were January like with snowing returning but even in West Yorkshire the week has been a bit of a trial as northerly brought through hail storms on a regular basis.  It made for yet another testing track session on Friday; resulting in a set of 8 x 600 reps much slower than recent 10K pace! very frustrating.
 But all in all concluding with a solid 8 today (thanks for the company, John) it was another "par" week of 41 miles.
  There's a rare evening race to be tackled this week.  Thursday evening sees the first of 5 races in the MANCHESTER PARK GRAND PRIX SERIES,  the SALFORD 5K.   If you object to paying the high entry fees that many races seem to charge these days then this series is worth considering.   5 races for just £20 for club runners; £30 if unattached.
 EVENT ONE............SALFORD 5K  THURSDAY  APRIL 26 7 PM (new faster course)
 EVENT TWO...........SALE 5M          SUNDAY      MAY    27   11 AM
 EVENT  THREE.......PLATT FIELDS 10K  SUN    JUNE    24    11 AM
 EVENT  FOUR........DEBDALE PARK 7K  SUN   JULY      8    11  AM
 EVENT  FIVE ........BOGGART CHASE 10K SUN SEPT    16    11.15 AM
    Check out              WWW.FIVERACES.CO.UK


       

Saturday, 21 April 2012

MARATHON TAPER....at least for some.

I was in the Ilkley shop a week last Wednesday evening when a slim, fit looking young man came in and said he needed some shoes for tomorrow's LONDON MARATHON.  I asked him how his training was going.  He said he hadn't done any running yet; he had only taken up the chance to run take part in the marathon the previous Friday, 4 days earlier!
                I naturally queried what training he had done in the last 4 days then.  Nothing!
Restraining the strong desire to launch into a rant about people who treat the 26.2 mile event with such apparent "contempt" I just went about selling the young man a pair of £90 shoes. At least he was treating his feet with respect.  As a fairly fit, regular football playing young man he'll no doubt finish.  But  it certainly won't be a "fun run" as he probably hopes it will be.  When he reaches the Tower at 22 miles he is unlikely to be running and sadly is unlikely to be having any fun.
  So he was starting his marathon build up from scratch 10 days before the event. Very much an exception. In contrast  my friend SALLY M. was bringing our  marathon programme to near conclusion with a mile rep session (4) 10 days before the MANCHESTER MARATHON.  Achieving 6.40  mile pace in foul, cold and wet April conditions should make 7.15 mileing feel reasonably comfortable ....at least for 15 miles or so before she has to dig deep as she did in the heat of Barcelona (see pic.)   Her longest run has been 24 miles which she ran at an average of 8.12. One minute slower than target  marathon pace.  Any faster and she would not have been able to cope with two speed sessions in the following 8 days.  12 x 600  4 days later and 5 x mile 4 days after that.
 I fully anticipate the energy will come flooding back now for her with 10 days of easy running, punctuated by just 6 x 1 minute next Tuesday to remind the legs a tad about pace.
 Described in his book, from last to first, CHARLIE SPEDDING'S last week  before his 2:09.58 Olympic Marathon included 5 x 400 on the Wednesday in 60.9! average.  Long run wise he states "I think it is important to run further than the marathon on one occasion  about 3 weeks prior" to the race.
 He ran 28 miles in 2:55;  6:15 per mile.
 He ran a 5 mile race 7 days before the marathon.  24.09......4: 48 pace
 He ran the Olympic marathon at 4.58 pace.
  So no intent it seems to run his long run anywhere near  "marathon pace" (MP) because after 2 days steady running he had to come back on the third day after running 28 miles with a track session of 10 x 400 , followed two days later with an 18 miler including intervals!


 Going back to the LONDON, the race for the third and last Olympic womens place will be of great interest. Echoed by this week's A.W. cover.  It's perhaps fortunate that the selectors didn't insist on Yamauchi and Paul Radcliffe racing tomorrow as well.   Paula's 72.03 in the Vienna Half marathon was good enough to win and take her to second in this year's UK rankings BUT  suggests as of today she is "only" in shape to run around 2:33. a time which won't be seeing her add to medals tally.    She was once again "distressed" after the race, mouthing apologies to the race organiser. Not good.  The planned handicap race with Haile G. did not come about as Haile passed t Paula after 5k!
 But  there is no doubt that to have suffered bronchitis this year and only just come off antibiotics will have detracted from  her performance and  she will be hoping to run better in the LONDON OLYMPIC marathon.
Cynics would say she had to run to top up the bank balance, of course. But whatever,  if it were me I would be looking for another half marathon to restore confidence that she can run well under 70 minutes .....and so under 2:30......whether there was a cheque at the end of it or not!  
 I would have her reducing the quantity of weekly miles and running several quality races to restore confidence.  To me she just isn't "in the sport" as she should and could be. The pressure of running less than a dozen high profile races per year must be immense.
  As always  we'll be settling down to watch tomorrow's race.  We'll be trying to spot some of the FASTRAX vests we've been sending out out for the last month.  But I think spotting my young novice customer might prove difficult amongst the masses. Hopefully the experience which is bound to be traumatic will not put him off running altogether!
 If you are reading this before running London ...why?....you should be eating doughnuts!  Have a good one!

Tuesday, 17 April 2012

10K Race recovery..according to the book

   Bob Glover in his book, the COMPETITIVE RUNNER'S handbook, suggests that our post race recovery  should be to "run easy for the same number of days after a race as the number of miles of the event".
It's an adage I've been aware of for probably a couple of decades but I would suggest along with the majority of club runners it's generally advice not adhered to.
  When was the last time you "ran easy" for 6/7 days after a 10K race?
I would suggest with so many club nights on a Tuesday many don't resist getting taken away on a hard session by others who haven't raced 48 hours previously.
   My return to anything near race pace has gradually extended  over the last decade from Wednesday to Thursday to Friday after a Sunday race.  But last week following the SALFORD 10K on Good Friday I was happy to comply with Glover's advice.  Few of the 25 miles after the event had been under 9 minute mileing.  But as the toll of the event dissipated  it was reinject some pace into the running;  it was pleasing to thrash out a tempo 3 miles (7.37 7.41 7.07) last  Friday.  It was  7 days after the race.  I could see Glover nodding in approval.

 NATIONAL 12/6 ROAD RELAYS

  The first email I opened immediately after the Friday session was one from Dave R. at the club  appealing for runners to make up the "B" for the NATIONAL 12 man relay the following day as several selected had withdrawn as the week developed from both the "A" and "B" team.
 If I hadn't made plans to go up to the Lake District and hadn't done the tempo session I would have gone down to Birmingham.   As it turned out the withdrawals became signuficant  as the "A" team dipped from 5th at halfway to 24th.  The "B" team  was 4 men short in the end; so I would have run in an incomplete team for yet another time.
 I heard the view expressed a couple of times last week that "Birmingham is a long way to go and it's a whole day out".   My reply was that runners will be travelling across the world to run under 10 seconds in the Olympics!
 Still it was good to see that 61 teams DID support the national event including CORSTOPHINE and SHETTLESTONE from Scotland and LES CROUPIERS from South Wales in the mens race.
ALDERSHOT  went up from Hampshire with a team full of internationals to win the womens event. Respect.
  I can't help but think that those who have never run at Sutton Park and withdrew missed taking part in a great National event.   Long may it continue!
  LONGSLEDDALE SUNDAY 10

The week was concluded with a favourite Lake District road run; up and down the Longsleddale valley ,north of Keswick.   A cold biting headwind robbed much of the pleasure from the upward 5 but true to form I was 5 minutes faster with the tail wind.  4 cars passed me in 10 miles of running ;  surely one of THE "quietest" roads in the Lake district.   
                       Hopefully the first of a few runs on that route in 2012.
  

 


Monday, 9 April 2012

Guiseley Gallop video

 Ten years ago,  during  some training run banter when I was running with Ilkley Harriers,  one of the "fellrunners" suggested I should run a fell race some time. I said I would if he would do a road race and by the end of the run an Easter  "3 races in 3 days challenge" was on the cards......at least in my mind!
 My teammate thought I wasn't being serious  and failed to run any events but the idea had got into my mind and I determined to do it.
So having run the Salford 10K on the Friday (37.04) followed by the Rivington Pike fell race on the Saturday I lined up for the multi-terrain Guiseley Gallop 10K race on Easter Sunday and ran in a very tired 42.37.
The following year, 2003, I opted to miss the Saturday race out, running the Salford in 38.13 followed by a near repeat at the Gallop of 42.47.
  But time takes a toll and nowadays  after Friday's 10K  it was all I could do to jog 3 miles on Saturday and the 4 yesterday wasn't much easier.  Very tired again ...after just ONE race.
 Yesterday then, Easter Sunday,  Pat and I attended the Gallop to give support and in doing so did a bit of filming.  Hope you enjoy.............

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=H41uJLvNnS4


Saturday, 7 April 2012

NEGATIVE THOUGHTS BUT NEGATIVE SPLITS AT THE SALFORD 10K


Yesterday  marked a return to the Good Friday fixture which was the first Senior road race I ran in at the age of 18 back in 1967. Back then it was called the "Willam Howarth 7.5" mile road race
(or the Salford 7 for short!). The race was won by RON HILL in 35.36.  There were only 100 competitors, all members of local clubs,  with the last runner running 52.36. No women took part.
I ran 30th in 39.55.  DEREK WALTON (Altrincham) also ran yesterday as he did 45 years ago.
We would appear to have been the sole survivors with Stan Curran marshalling.
 I must admit to being pretty apprehensive and a bit negative this  week as the fixture (now the  SALFORD 10K)   approached.   The perceived fragility of the old legs  is a major factor for concern.  The feeling being...... "you never know when the wheels are ready to come off".
 The race would either confirm calf problems or be a welcome boost to the confidence.
 I think it's always very easy for us to say we're not 100% and put off racing but  I thought it was time to grasp the nettle and just determine how fit or relatively unfit I am at present.   Only racing would give me the feedback necessary to go forward.  Solo training times are no real indication.
 Another concern earlier in the week was the weather of course.  But fortunately   Scotland and the North east bore the brunt of the blizzards.   Wharfedale was only affected at high level and so there was no problem getting in 4 easy days of 4,4,3, and 3  miles as I tried to ease up for what ostensibly my first "measured" race of 2012.
 All this considered  the check list of kit had me covering all options.............
  Racing shoes and training shoes (just in case)............I opted for the trainers.
 Socks and support socks (just in case)......................I opted for the support sicks.
 Long sleeve and   short sleeve  (just in case)..............I opted for the short sleeve.
Thermal hat and cap (just in case)..............................I opted for the cap
Sunglasses (just in case).............................................Sadly not needed.
Gloves (just in case)..................................................Not needed by race time.
Support shorts (or shorts (just in case).......................Shorts!
  The sunglasses weren't required;  it was a distinctly cold morning but fortunately devoid of wind. So conditions favourable for once.
  Last year I was quite satisfied to open up with a 43.28 on March 5 at Blackpool 's Stanley Park.  So  given  a year older veteran sages would suggest 30 seconds slower would to be expected.  But in truth  I  just had it in mind to keep every K split around or under 4.30 to give me 44.30 to 45 minutes.  Possibly over cautious?
 With adrenalin levels recording low it was no surprise then to see 4.33 as we passed the opening K marker.
(The race is not chipped, so possibly a touch faster) . A slight pick up then with 4.23 4.27  4.15 and 4.23 as we went through 5K in 22.03  and the first lap flyers are rapidly coming back!
  It's a 2 lap course and with the good chance of a sub 44 time somehow , from somewhere, the adrenalin finally kicked in,  particularly from the 7K mark with  very pleasing final Ks of 4.08  4.16  4.08.  The results
suggest I overtook over 40 runners on the second lap as some I was with at 5K finished over 2 minutes behind.
Conclusion?  I need to inject the adrenalin before the start!  Get up and away a bit better from the gun and again make time for a more thorough warm up!  
My negative splits read well, with  22.03 and 21.26,  but that first 5k needs to be sharper to get back under 43.  In my defence I would say "psyching up" for what was my 140th 10K in a time very near the bottom of 10K times takes some doing!  
 As for many runners around me clearly a lot need  to address the balance between speed work and speed/endurance.  So many running quite clearly running positive splits.
  43.29 which was only good enough for 4th of 19 in the M60 category,  242nd of 533.  The addage of year older 30 seconds slower seemed spot on.  2011 42.59; 2012  43.29 !
 A good quality field as always  was  lead in by JACK MARTIN (29.50) followed by Stockport clubmate ANDY NIXON (30.12). Versatile LIZZIE ADAMS, a frequent winner on XC, fell and trail demonstrated  that top off road runners need good flat speed also with a PB of 32.50.
 So that was the Salford done and dusted for another year.  It's not the most scenic of events  and there's quite a bit of hopping from the road to pavements.  But  the course is as flat as you'll get, parking is good, there's changing/showers. It's finally been K marked after years of "nagging".  Prizes are a bit shallow for vets though; surprising as Salford H is such a strong vets club.  
  So a late start to the 2012 season, quite satisfying but room for improvement!